“The CCRC referred his case to this court because, following the decision of the House of Lords in Morgan Smith [2001] 1 AC 146, and given a new assertion that the appellant had been the victim of childhood sexual abuse, there was doubt that the issue of provocation had properly been before the jury…”
To read [...]
Filed under: Case link, Homicide | Leave a Comment »
“It is well established that a genuine but mistaken belief can be relied upon as a defence to a criminal charge such as false imprisonment where the Crown have to prove that the defendant’s conduct was unlawful. This principle is well illustrated by the case of R v Gladstone Williams [1984] 78 CAR 276 where [...]
Filed under: Case link, Defences | Leave a Comment »
“This appeal from the Court of Appeal of Jersey calls for examination of the law relating to provocation as a defence or, more precisely, as a partial defence to a charge of murder. Jersey law on this subject is the same as English law. In July 2000 the House of Lords considered the ingredients of [...]
Filed under: Case link, Homicide | Leave a Comment »
“My Lords, of all crimes manslaughter appears to afford most difficulties of definition, for it concerns homicide in so many and so varying conditions. From the early days when any homicide involved penalty the law has gradually evolved ” through ” successive differentiations and integrations” until it recognises
murder on the one hand, based mainly though [...]
Filed under: Case link, Homicide | Leave a Comment »
“My Lords, it has been strenuously and ably argued for the respondent that these provisions involve that a defendant is liable to conviction for an attempt even where his actions are innocent but he erroneously believes facts which, if true, would make those actions criminal, and further, that he is liable to such conviction whether [...]
Filed under: Attempt, Case link | Leave a Comment »
